Oct 20, 2016

PSPED Responds to CEC3 Rezoning Letter to DOE

Rezoning for a few D3 schools
October 19, 2016

Dear CEC3 and DOE,

In June, we brought a short document to the CEC rezoning hearing, “Principles for Equity in District 3.” A principled commitment to school equity always matters, and it particularly matters here because the current rezoning process ignores the underlying problem -- extreme inequality among District 3 schools -- and diverts time and attention from solutions that address that crisis.

[A PDF version of this letter is here.]

School inequality in District 3 is not new, but has been growing for over a decade as wealthier families have looked at certain schools as “schools of choice,” and used a range of privileged means to gain seats for their children. The current overcrowding in lower District 3 and under-enrollment in upper District 3 are a result of parents who can afford it either moving into high-cost housing that’s zoned for more-resourced schools or, if they live in the northern part of the district, finding ways to avoid sending their children to their zoned school. As a result, “schools of choice” become even more privileged places, where privileged families clamor for spots. Struggling schools are left to less privileged families and are often under-enrolled as privileged families who live nearby refuse to attend. Rezoning does nothing to address the cause of this. It only puts a band-aid on the symptoms.

Fixing this imbalance demands an equity plan. Rezoning is not a solution to problems of overcrowding, segregation, or inequity in schools, but focuses instead on the immediate symptoms of inequity, and only in a few mostly high-income schools. (It addresses one struggling, under-enrolled school by widening its zone rather than addressing the reasons for under-enrollment.) The current three-year rezoning process has delivered the message that the CEC and DOE are primarily responsive to the concerns of privileged families. The right of other students to an equal and adequate education seems an afterthought. School inequity does not even appear as a goal in the CEC’s goals or DOE’s proposals. “Diversity,” without any definition, is mentioned as something to “consider.”

Neither is rezoning a long-term solution for lower District 3. As long as families can buy their way in and out of zones, the gains made through rezoning will fade and schools will once again become as unequal as the district’s real estate. It’s time for New York City policymaking to adopt a fair admissions policy that removes wealth as a bargaining chip for education.

Public School Parents for Equity and Desegregation asks the CEC and DOE to meaningfully consider Community-Controlled Choice as a long-term solution that will better equalize and integrate schools. The CEC has not yet engaged in a real community process on any school equity plans, and the CEC chair and the Zoning Committee chair have been opposed to Community-Controlled Choice. Contrary to the CEC’s October 18th letter, the two panels it did host on Community-Controlled Choice did not result in “more questions than panelists could answer.” The panelists answered that specifics must be determined by the community through an engagement process that runs scenarios using different controls. It is not true that there was no explanation of the consequences of Title I funding changes at affected schools: very simply, Community-Controlled Choice can preserve Title I by allocating low-income students to a school. Dismissing Community-Controlled Choice as unattainable because it might need “years of strategic planning, stakeholder engagement, and analysis” is an insult, considering we’ve just witnessed this three-year rezoning process, catered to families who are accustomed to benefitting from unequal schools and the school-buying power of real estate.

We ask also for the DOE and CEC to start fairly representing all families. Equal schools and educational justice must be a first principle. Making plans any other way will deepen and prolong overcrowding, segregation and inequity.

Signed,


Toni Smith-Thompson (Mott Hall 2 parent)

Yassiel Nieves (PS 145 parent)

Chris Parkman (PS 75 parent)

Kavita Singh (MSC/PS 333 parent)


on behalf of Public School Parents for Equity and Desegregation’s (NYC PSPED) District 3 Members

Oct 19, 2016

PSPED información para padres

PSPED información para padres (el original està aquí.)

PSPED información para padres (el original està aquí.)

PSPED flyer for parents

PSPED flyer for parents (download the original here.)


Aug 24, 2016

¡Primera reunión de PSPED! 1 de Septiembre

Queridos madres y padres interesados en la justicia social,

Padres de Familia por la Equidad y la Desegregación en las Escuelas Públicas de NYC (NYC PSPED) vamos a celebrar nuestra primera reunión. ¡Por favor únase a nosotros! Estamos construyendo nuestra comunidad de padres de familia activistas. Cada persona es importante y se necesita!

El jueves, 1 de Septiembre
de 6pm a 8pm
39 West 105th Street, soutane
(cerca de Central Park West y de las estaciones de los trenes B/C.)

NIÑOS: Los niños son bienvenidos, van a ver una película en otra habitación.
COMIDA: Habrá pizza y frutas / verduras para todo el mundo.
IDIOMAS: La reunión será en inglés y español. Si se necesita traducción a otros idiomas, por favor háganoslo saber.

* RSVP: un RSVP se aprecia para fines de planificación. Por favor confirmar su asistencia a través de (917) 517-3627 o nycpsped@gmail.com.

SOBRE LA REUNIÓN

La reunión incluirá información y discusión sobre las siguientes preguntas:

¿Cómo son el proceso de selección y el plan de integración / patrimonio controlado por la comunidad que se propusieron en Brooklyn y D3 (Upper West Side / Harlem)? ¿Cómo pueden los padres hacer que suceda, y asegurarse de que se ha hecho bien?
¿Cuáles son los asuntos en las escuelas específicas a las que nuestros hijos asisten? Juntar nuestros conocimientos acerca de lo que son la desigualdad y la segregación - y también cómo ciertas escuelas están haciendo las cosas mejor - fortalecerá en gran medida nuestras demandas de soluciones reales.
¿Qué tenemos que hacer (los padres) para presionar al DOE y CEC locales (consejos comunitarios de educación) para que implementen soluciones a la desigualdad y la segregación escolar? ¿Qué podemos hacer a nivel de escuela, a nivel de distrito, y en el plano de la ciudad? ¿Qué podemos hacer ahora para contrarrestar los mensajes a menudo racistas e irrespetuosos planteados en reuniones públicas sobre las escuelas?
Después de discutir lo anterior, identificaremos las acciones más importantes en las que hay que trabajar, encontraremos la manera de organizarnos a través de pequeños grupos de trabajo y estableceremos un calendario de reuniones.


Para su información, otros temas importantes para nuestro grupo son:

.... Qué otras soluciones se están discutiendo que los padres deben proponer? (Por ejemplo, ingresos compartidos de la PTA)

... ¿Cómo podemos ayudar a nuestras escuelas a construir planes de estudios en torno a los movimientos y los problemas que afectan actualmente nuestras vidas - incluyendo Black Lives Matter, la islamofobia y otros?

* RSVP: un RSVP se aprecia para fines de planificación. Por favor confirmar su asistencia a través de (917) 517-3627 o nycpsped@gmail.com.  ¡Gracias!

PSPED's first meeting! Sept. 1, 6pm

Dear Justice-minded Parents,

NYC PSPED will be holding our first community meeting. Please join us. We are just building our community of parent activists. Everyone counts and is needed!!
Thursday, Sept. 1, from 6-8pm
at 39 West 105th Street, Basement
(near Central Park West, close to B/C trains.)

KIDS: Kids are welcome; they will watch a movie in another room.
FOOD:  There will be pizza and fruit/veggies for everyone.
LANGUAGES:  The meeting will be in English and Spanish. If translations to other languages is needed, please let us know.

*An RSVP is appreciated for planning purposes.  Please RSVP via (917) 517-3627 or nycpsped@gmail.com.

About the meeting

The meeting will include information and discussion on:

What is Community-Controlled Choice, the desegregation/equity plan that's proposed in Brooklyn and D3 (Upper West side / Harlem)?  How can parents make it happen and make sure it's done well?
What are the issues in the specific schools our kids attend? Pooling our knowledge about what inequity and segregation look like -- and also how individual schools are making things work, will greatly strengthen our demands for real solutions.
What should we (parents) do to move the DOE and local CECs (community education councils) to act on solutions toward school inequity and segregation?  What can we do at the school level, at the district level - and at the city level? What can we do now to counter the often racist, disrespectful messages raised in public meetings about schools?
After discussing the above, we can identify the most important actions to work on, figure out how to organize (through smaller workgroups), and set a meeting schedule.

Other topics important to our group include looking at:

.... What other solutions are being discussed and what should parents be pushing for?  (e.g. PTA income-sharing)

.... How can we move and help our schools to build curricula around the movements and issues currently affecting our lives -- including Black Lives Matter, Islamophobia, and others?

* RSVP: An RSVP is appreciated for planning purposes.  Please RSVP via (917) 517-3627 or nycpsped@gmail.com.  Thank you!